Sheriff's
office investigates mayors
Report
on Clough, Knoble going to ethics panel
By Kevin Kelley
Westlake
Published Jan. 11, 2006
The
Cuyahoga County Sheriff’s Office will turn over to the Ohio Ethics
Commission its findings regarding the employment of relatives of
the mayors of Westlake and Rocky River at the Rocky River Wastewater
Treatment Plant.
On Sunday, The Plain Dealer Sunday quoted Sheriff’s
Inspector Rob Havranek saying the Sheriff’s office will recommend
that a special prosecutor be assigned to review the case. However,
Havranek told West Life this was incorrect.
“I was misquoted,” Havranek said Monday.
The Sheriff’s office has completed its investigation
for all intents and purposes, Havranek said, and is in the process
of finalizing its report. The results of the investigation will
be forwarded to the Ohio Ethics Commission, which is scheduled to
meet in February, he said.
The investigation grew out of an Oct. 13 Plain Dealer
story which reported five relatives of Westlake Mayor Dennis Clough
and two relatives Rocky River Mayor William Knoble were employed
at the Rocky River Wastewater Treatment Plant.
Clough and Knoble serve on the plant’s management
board. Employees of the plant are technically employees of the city
of Rocky River.
At the time the article was published, Clough was
in the middle of a heated campaign for re-election against Westlake
school board member Joe O’Malley. The mayor was elected to a sixth
consecutive term in the Nov. 8 election, defeating O’Malley 72 to
28 percent.
At the time, Clough told West Life he believed the
article was politically motivated. He also said it was not inappropriate
for him to be used as a reference for a relative.
After reviewing the Sheriff’s report, the state ethics
panel will relay any findings back to the Sheriff, Havranek said.
He added the Sheriff’s office still planned to present a report
to the county prosecutor for review after the Ohio Ethics Commission
has ruled.
A spokesperson for Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill
Mason told West Life Monday that office has not received a formal
recommendation from the Sheriff’s office.
Jamie Dalton, public information officer at the prosecutor’s
office, said it was her understanding that the Sheriff’s investigation
was still ongoing. The Sheriff’s office has been passing along information
related to the case to the prosecutor, Dalton said.
According to an Ohio Ethics Commission publication,
Ohio law prohibits officials from hiring family members; however,
ethics laws do not prohibit family members from being employed by
the same public agency as an official as long as the official has
not secured or authorized the job for the relative.
A public official also is not generally prohibited
from approving a union contract when a relative is a member of the
union, according to the Ohio Ethics Commission.
Clough noted his family members grew up in Rocky River
and have the same right to serve the citizens of that city as he
does the citizens of Westlake.
“They all went through an interview process, and I
didn’t do the hiring,” Clough said in October. “I wouldn’t recommend
someone who couldn’t do a job.
“If people can do the job, they ought to have the
same consideration and they shouldn’t be excluded.”
Clough did not return calls to West Life earlier this
week concerning the Sheriff’s report being forwarded to the Ohio
Ethics Commission.
When contacted by West Life Monday, Knoble said he
could not comment because the investigation is ongoing. He also
said his attorney, Michael Murman has advised him not to comment.
“Hopefully at some point I will be able to issue a
statement,” Knoble said. “Obviously I continue to believe I’ve done
nothing wrong.”
|