Liam Fay didn’t have the game he wanted Friday night, but more than anything, he was just thrilled to take part.

The North Olmsted quarterback was one of nine local athletes chosen to represent the West team in the 47th annual Cuyahoga County East-West All-Star game at George Finnie Stadium in Berea. Joining Fay were teammates offensive lineman Evan Grablovic and linebacker Ricky Scott.

Three players apiece from Lutheran West and Fairview also made the West team roster. Longhorn defensive backs Gerald McHenry and DeAnte Furry and defensive lineman Kevin McLeeson joined Warriors running back Jack Provenza, linebacker Tommy McNamara and offensive lineman Justin Grealis.

Unfortunately, the 41-member West team came up short to a firepower-filled East team, losing 23-8. Garfield Heights quarterback Marlon Jordan paced his team as he passed for 153 yard and one touchdown on 15-24 passing – good enough to make the Ashland University commit the MVP for the East. John Marshall’s Julian Banks was the MVP for the West.

Fay had nearly as much yardage (127) as Jordan but struggled with accuracy and drops, going 16-33 for one touchdown and three interceptions. After the game, though, Fay didn’t seem to mind.

“First of all, getting picked to play in this game is an honor,” Fay said. “Getting to play with teams from around here and kids that I don’t even know; come together, play and get to know each other and play the game we love (was a fun time).”

Fay’s favorite target was John Marshall’s John Jackson who had four catches but just six yards. Three receivers had three catches (Cleveland Central Catholic’s Cody Bell, 48 yards; Rhodes’ Chase McMichael, 28 yards and Banks, 25 yards, touchdown).

Banks’ touchdown was the only time the West found the end zone in the game. Following an East safety on the previous drive, Fay and St. Ignatius running back Jahadge Floyd took the West 44 yards in five plays, capped with an eight-yard touchdown pass. Fay’s two-point conversion pass failed and the West trailed 10-8.

The East opened the scoring on its first drive. Jordan had great field position to work with after Banks, who also punted for the West, had a punt go straight up in the air and bounce back for a loss of 13 yards, setting the East up on the West’s 38-yard line. It took just three plays, all passes, for the East to go up 7-0.

Fay’s first of three picks came on the next West drive and though the East didn’t turn it into another touchdown, Beachwood kicker Sam Babbush knocked down a 42-yard field goal with ease to put his team up 10-0.

The East added one more touchdown following Banks’ score – a one-yard score by Jordan – and another in the fourth – a three-yard rush by Chagrin Falls’ Mick Lawrence. Following the latter, in a strange sight, Chagrin Falls O-lineman Henry Woofter attempted, and had blocked, a drop kick for the extra point.

In a last-ditch effort, the West marched down the field in under three minutes to the East’s seven-yard line, but an incomplete pass on fourth down ended the game.


The All-Star game’s intent to showcase the best players in Cuyahoga County didn’t stop either team from playing at full intensity.

In the fourth quarter, with the East firmly ahead 17-8 and driving down the field, an East player was called for an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. One play later, both teams were called for offsetting unsportsmanlike penalties. After the East pushed the score to 23-8, following the ensuing kickoff, there was another pair of offsetting penalties of the same kind, bringing the total unsportsmanlike count to five in just 14 plays.


After playing together at Lutheran West, Furry and McHenry will head to Concordia Ann Arbor to continue their football and educational careers. On Friday, the pair totaled five tackles, with the former also adding a pass breakup.

“I never thought I would play with rival teammates or with my teammates ever again,” Furry said. “I’m looking forward to meeting new people and playing on a different team. At Lutheran West they teach you how to be a man and what life is really going to be like and give you experience for it.”


Friday’s game gave Grablovic a chance to play with some of his teammates one last time as a North Olmsted Eagle as well an opportunity to get a feel for Baldwin Wallace, where he will attend college and play football.

“It was kinda cool. The field is really nice. They just put it in last year,” the North Olmsted lineman said. “When we played Berea-Midpark last year we actually played here. I’m ready to build a lot of good friendships with other people coming to BW to play football.”

Contact this reporter at or 440-871-5797.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.